Butler Homes with Garrett High School

Welcome to Butler, Indiana, a charming township nestled within the scenic landscapes of DeKalb County. Just a stone's throw away from the vibrant city of Auburn, Butler offers a unique blend of small-town charm and convenient access to urban amenities. Known for its friendly community and rich history, Butler is an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

One of the standout features of Butler is its proximity to Garrett High School, making it a fantastic location for families with school-aged children. The school is renowned for its commitment to academic excellence and a wide range of extracurricular activities that help foster well-rounded students. Living in Butler means your children can enjoy the benefits of a quality education without the hassle of long commutes.

The real estate landscape in Butler is diverse, featuring a mix of charming historic homes and modern residences that cater to various tastes and budgets. Whether you're searching for a cozy starter home or a spacious property to accommodate a growing family, Butler has something to offer everyone. The township's peaceful atmosphere, coupled with well-maintained parks and recreational facilities, creates a perfect backdrop for family life.

In addition to its residential appeal, Butler boasts easy access to major highways, making commutes to nearby cities a breeze. With its strong sense of community, excellent schools, and beautiful homes, Butler, IN is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Come discover the charm of Butler and find your dream home today!

Newest Butler Homes with Garrett High School

$849,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202630037 MLS ⋅ 5,098 SqFt. ⋅ Gregory Brown

Start Showing Date: 8/5/2026 *Listing coming soon, showings start on August 5th at noon!! *Nestled on five picturesque acres, this exceptional custom-built estate offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and peaceful country living—just minutes from shopping, hospitals, and restaurants. *Thoughtfully designed with impeccable craftsmanship and no detail spared, this stunning home features 4 bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths, and a private den, creating an ideal retreat for everyday living and entertaining. *Step inside to discover elegant custom crown molding, tray ceilings, and luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout. *The inviting formal dining room flows seamlessly into the chef's kitchen, complete with stainless steel appliances, abundant custom cabinetry, and a charming breakfast nook overlooking the expansive deck and serene backyard. *The desirable split-bedroom floor plan provides privacy, with a luxurious primary suite featuring a spa-inspired bath with a relaxing garden tub, beautifully tiled walk-in shower, and generous closet space. *The walk-out lower level is an entertainer's dream, offering an additional bedroom, a fully equipped wet bar, an oversized great room, recreation room, bonus room, spacious laundry room, abundant storage, and direct access to the patio. *Outdoor living is equally impressive with multiple spaces to relax and enjoy the scenic surroundings, including a spacious deck, patio, charming garden shed, and a tranquil pond that enhances the property's peaceful setting. *A 4-car garage, 20' x 20' storage shed, and extensive storage throughout provide exceptional functionality. *This remarkable property combines refined living with the beauty of a private country oasis, offering the perfect balance of seclusion and convenience in a truly one-of-a-kind setting.

2098 County Road 66 Road, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Gregory Brown from CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc. Cell: 260-602-5297

$197,700

202541348 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 13 is sized nice at 2.94 acres and is partially wooded and sits on a Cul-de-sac. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this Brand New Sub Division and pick your lot out today.

1742 Pietrelcina Ct Lot 13, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$181,900

202541347 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 12 is a 2.22 acre lot. This lot sits in a Cul-de-sac and has the potential for a Daylight Basement. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this Brand New Sub Division and pick your lot out today.

1730 Pietrelcina Ct Lot 12, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$189,900

202541345 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 10 is a nice sized lot at 2.40 acres and sits on a Cud-de-sac. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this Brand New Sub Division and pick your lot out today.

1737 Pietrelcina Ct Lot 10, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$197,700

202541344 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 9 is a nice size at 2.71 Acres and has a nice thick private tree line at the back of the property. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this Brand New Sub Division and pick your lot out today.

6550 Padre Pio Dr Lot 9, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$197,700

202541343 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 8 is a nice sized lot at 2.71 acres. This lot sits on a Cul-de-sac and is partially wooded. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this brand new Subdivision and pick out your lot today.

6534 Padre Pio Dr Lot 8, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$189,900

202541340 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 5 is 2.71 acres that sits in a Cul-de-sac and could possibly be built with a Daylight basement. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots. Come and tour this brand new addition and get your lot picked out.

6535 Padre Pio Dr Lot 5, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$189,900

202541339 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new addition with nice sized lots for private county living. Lot 4 features 2.71 acres and has the possibility of a daylight basement. FIOS Internet is scheduled to be installed in 2026 so no slow internet connections here. Soil test have been done for each lot and are all septic approved. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Come and tour the addition and pick your lot out today.

6551 Padre Pio Dr Lot 4, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$191,200

202541338 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 3 is a very nice 2.54 acre lot with a possibility of a Daylight Basement. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots.

6565 Padre Pio Dr Lot 3, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$181,900

202541336 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 2 is an excellent 2.29 acre lot near the entrance of the subdivision. On this lot a Daylight basement is a possibility. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots.

6581 Padre Pio Dr Lot 2, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$179,900

202541335 MLS ⋅ Jason Holman

Welcome to Rotondo Estates. This is a brand new subdivision with large lots for Private county living. Lot 1 is an excellent 3.11 acre lot near the entrance of the subdivision. There are plenty of build location options on this lot and a Daylight basement is a possibility. FIOS Internet is to be installed in 2026. County Road 17 is to be surfaced sometime in 2026 for a nice clean drive to the Subdivision. All homes built will have a minimum of 2,500 sqft for a ground floor area and a minimum of 3,000 sqft for all two stories. Matching outbuildings/pole barns are permitted. Septic sites have been approved for all the lots.

1781 Padre Pio Dr Lot 1, Auburn

Listing courtesy of Jason Holman from Indiana Real Estate. Cell: 260-466-9644

$299,000

202427543 MLS ⋅ Tammie Jones

Escape the hustle and bustle of city life and embrace the tranquility of rural living with our rural lots. Nestled among mature trees and accessible via a charming gravel road, these secluded properties offer the perfect blend of privacy and serenity. Imagine waking up each morning to the sounds of nature, surrounded by the beauty of towering trees and the fresh, crisp air. Our lots provide the ideal setting for those seeking a peaceful retreat, away from the noise and distractions of urban living. These spacious and private lots are perfect for building your dream home, and the rustic charm of the gravel road enhances the rural appeal. With specific building restrictions in place, you can maintain the aesthetic integrity of the area. All homes must feature log cedar siding, blending seamlessly with the natural surroundings. Additionally, benefit from the excellent education provided by the nearby Garrett High School, ensuring a bright future for your family. Don't miss this unique opportunity to own a piece of paradise. Whether you're looking to build your forever home or a weekend getaway, our rural lots offer the perfect canvas for your vision. Some of this lot is in a flood zone. May be sold with lot 5 or 9.

6769 County Road 7a, Garrett

Listing courtesy of Tammie Jones from Open Door Rentals and Real Est. 260-333-7368

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated